To download a printable version of this transcript, click here.
iQuestions Faculty, Ron Blue
Question:
What is the envelope system?
Answer:
JUDY BLUE: The envelope system is a great tool and a great friend to
both parents and children. We used it when our children were growing
up—with five children, obviously there can be a lot of conflict over
money. How much can I spend on this outfit? How much can I spend
to buy so-and-so’s birthday present?
In scripture, it says, “There are three things, yea, four, that never say
‘enough.’” (Proverbs 30:15) And, children don’t ever say “enough”
either, but it’s not on that list in Proverbs. So, they always want more,
bigger and better.
So, the envelope system is a training system that is so freeing to both
parents and children. Basically, you have five envelopes: Spending,
saving, clothes, tithing, and gifts—and the gifts are for people in the
family for Christmas and birthdays, and it also included little gifts for
their birthday parties that they got to attend. Clothes were the clothes
that they cared about.
I think that’s really important to understand. Our youngest was five
when we started him on the envelope system. At that point in his life
he did not care about underwear, so he was not responsible for his
underwear. Church shoes and church clothes maybe never would have
gotten on anybody’s list.
So, what you make them responsible for in their particular envelope
are things that they will take ownership of. And then when you go
shopping they take their envelope with them, and they get to decide
how they’re going to spend that money. It’s a fascinating study in your
children’s personality. Some of them can’t wait to spend everything in
there. Some of them want to keep everything that’s in there. But
that’s okay! Ultimately, what you’re trying to do is teach them that
when the envelope is empty, they’re done spending.
It’s so interesting to see the difference in their perspective when it’s
money, even though it’s your money in their envelope, how much
more careful they are in looking at price tags.
RON BLUE: Do you mean Tim and Michael spent money differently?
JUDY: Yes, they did! It was so fascinating. You’d take them to the
store and one of our sons would rather have had two Polo shirts and
only have two shirts. And another son who would rather go to Wal-
Mart or Target and have as many shirts as his hundred dollars would
buy.
There’s freedom, there’s so much freedom, for the child and for you. If
the one who chose polo shirts had been spending out of my pocket, I
would not have let him do that. But because it was out of his pocket,
and there was a consequence for that choice, but he was okay with the
consequence, then it was very freeing.
RON: I think it’s important for people to understand that the money
that went into the envelope was money that we would have spent
anyway. We had a budget for our kids’ clothes, and we decided that
we were going to let them make the decision. So, they helped us set
the budget, but then we put it in the envelope, and it wasn’t just their
manipulation that got the amount. This was something we were going
Page -2-
to spend. So, what we did as a principle, we said we’re going to give
them the responsibility to spend that part of our budget.
I think there another thing that’s important to know, and that is that
you’ve been doing most of the talking on the envelope system—and
that’s with good reason, and that’s that you worked with it every day.
I worked with it a little bit, but I didn’t work with it like you did. You
had real commitment to doing it. You were the one that took them to
the mall and did the shopping, and so forth. We set up the system and
agreed on all the amounts. But as the mom, you were the one who
was the primary one committed to it.
JUDY: I want to encourage everybody to use the envelope system. Our
kids’ friends used to go home to their moms and say, “I want to do
what the Blues are doing.” Because, ultimately it’s a very empowering
system. Yes, it takes some management. Yes, you have to go to the
bank and get the cash. You have to be careful that your children are
respectful and careful about where they put their money.
But, the end result is so much freedom. We never had conflict with our
children about money.
RON: That’s a phenomenal statement! I was speaking one time and in
the audience was a group of very wealthy people. There was a couple
there that both of their parents were billionaires, and they had
married. Their question was, how do you ever teach your children that
there’s a limit? Especially in their situation, where there effectively was
no limit.
We talked about the envelope system, and you know, when the
envelope’s empty, the spending is done. What an incredible thing to
teach your child. This couple raised all their children on the envelope
system. They had billions of dollars and they raised their kids on the
envelope system, because it taught them that there’s a limit.
Page -3-
I think the other thing it taught them was regular giving.
Our kids, we required them, as a part of this system that they brought
the envelope to church, or they took the money out of the envelope,
the giving envelope. We taught them about saving. They could save
for a tennis racket, a bicycle or something. In other words, it was okay
to spend the saving envelope, which is right.
The book, Your Kids Can Master Their Money Too, which was published
by Focus on the Family, describes this whole money management
system that Judy and I have been talking about.
Page -4-
To download a printable version of this transcript, click here.
Related Videos
How should we help our grandchildren financially?
Watch Ron Blue's Answer
How much financial help should we give our adult children?
Watch Ron Blue's Answer
What are some creative gift ideas between grandparents and their grandchildren?
Watch Ron Blue's Answer